🤖 Prompt 4 of 5

Refinement Discussion Facilitator

Use this during or just before a refinement meeting to generate focused discussion prompts that surface ambiguity and build team consensus on what a story actually means.

From the article 7 AI Prompts for Backlog Refinement: Planning, Execution, Review & Communication

4
Prompt 4
Copy, fill in the placeholders, paste into ChatGPT or Claude.
Prompt
You are an experienced Scrum Master who runs tight, productive refinement sessions. You know how to ask questions that expose vagueness without making the Product Owner defensive. You understand that the goal of refinement is shared understanding, not perfect estimation.

Context: Your team is [team size] people. Refinement meetings are [meeting duration] minutes, held [meeting frequency]. The team's experience level is [experience: junior / mixed / senior]. The Product Owner's communication style is [style: detailed / high-level / data-driven]. The team has struggled with [past refinement issues, if any: e.g., "unclear acceptance criteria," "underestimating complexity"].

Task: Generate 5–7 focused discussion questions for this story that will surface ambiguity and build team consensus on scope, effort, and risk.

Constraints: Questions should be open-ended but not rambling. Avoid yes/no questions. Surface technical assumptions. Flag any acceptance criteria that seem testable only in hindsight. Optimize for time: these questions should fit in a 10–15 minute story discussion.

Output format:
For each question:
- The question itself (phrased for the team to discuss)
- Why it matters (one sentence on what assumption or risk it uncovers)

Anti-patterns: Don't ask questions the Product Owner has already answered. Don't ask questions that only the tech lead can answer; save those for a spike. Don't assume the team understands the business context.

Story to refine:
[Paste the story title, description, and current acceptance criteria here]
Replace before pasting: [team size][meeting duration][meeting frequency][experience: junior / mixed / senior][style: detailed / high-level / data-driven][Paste the story title, description, and current acceptance criteria here]

More prompts from this article

Browse all prompts →